A Pastoral Reflection on the I.C.E. Situation: Seeking Justice, Mercy, and Wisdom

 

The topic of immigration, especially the role of I.C.E. in enforcing our nation’s laws, has become one of the most deeply divisive and emotional issues in the United States today. As followers of Christ navigating this difficult terrain, it is important to resist broad strokes that label all Christians as extremists. Many of us, myself included, are peacemakers who believe both sides could give a little in order to reach a more civil and compassionate outcome. Amidst this complexity, how can we respond in a way that honors God, respects governing authorities, and reflects His love to all people? Never would I see all illegal immigrants as bad people. 

At the place I am the Executive Director we serve many migrants. Are they illegal? We don't know but we serve them in a judge free way as to maintain their dignity. 

In this blog, I will not focus on protestors or specific events. Instead, I am concentrating on the larger issue at hand. Regardless of which side of the fence one may be on, it is truly heartbreaking to witness both Americans and immigrants caught in such turmoil.

Governing Authorities and Our Christian Responsibility

The Bible provides clear guidance concerning our relationship to governing authorities. Romans 13:1-7 teaches us that all authority is established by God, and that believers are called to submit to those in leadership—not merely to avoid punishment but as a matter of conscience. The passage underscores that rulers are God’s servants, meant to promote good and restrain evil. Similarly, 1 Peter 2:13-17 exhorts believers to submit to every human institution, including kings and governors, paying taxes and showing respect as part of living honorably in a fallen world.

This submission is understood as general obedience, except in cases where a government command directly contradicts God’s laws. In such moments, obedience to God must take precedence, even when that brings risk or conflict.

The Reality of Immigration Statistics and Policy

It is important to note the statistical reality: during the Biden administration, the U.S. did not have “open borders.” However, a simple Google search would reveal that period did see record numbers of migrant encounters at the border, reflecting both systemic challenges and complex global immigration pressures. Nobody with a regard for law and order would argue that the proper way to enter the United States is not through customs, obtaining legal status such as a green card, and ultimately pursuing citizenship through lawful means.

Yet, many people entered or remained in the country without following those channels during this time. From a pastoral perspective, this raises urgent questions. While laws must be respected and enforced, is there a wiser or more compassionate way to address those already here? Is it possible to fast-track legal status for those who do not pose a criminal threat, rather than removing them altogether? Such approaches demand careful thought, balancing justice with mercy.

Criminals and Accountability

On this matter, virtually all would agree that individuals who commit crimes should be held accountable under the law and removed if they are here illegally. Upholding justice in this regard protects communities and maintains the integrity of our legal system. It does not contradict the pastoral call to love our neighbors or to care for the vulnerable.

The Call to Compassion and Hospitality

The Bible also commands us to care for strangers and show hospitality. Matthew 25:34, 40 reminds us that when we welcome the “least of these,” we are serving Christ Himself. Hebrews 13:2 advises us not to forget showing hospitality to strangers, for some have entertained angels without knowing it. These scriptures invite us to respond with kindness and compassion, even as we seek order and justice.

A Time for Grace Amidst a Distraught Political Landscape

We are living in challenging times. Political divisions run deep, and it can often feel as if neither side offers a fully adequate or compassionate solution. It is important to recognize that when we vote, we do not elect pastors, but presidents—human leaders who, like pastors and all of us, are imperfect and prone to mistakes. As Christians, our calling is to hold our leaders accountable while humbly remembering our own flaws, and above all, to reflect Christ’s love in our words and actions.

This requires humility, grace, and the courage to seek common ground beyond partisan lines. It also calls us to pray earnestly for wisdom, justice, and mercy to prevail.

In Conclusion

The issue of immigration enforcement by I.C.E. touches on matters of law, justice, compassion, and national security. As believers, we affirm the authority of government as instituted by God, commit to obeying laws, and seek peaceful, orderly societies. Yet we also champion mercy and hospitality as expressions of God’s heart for the stranger and vulnerable.

May we, as individuals and as a nation, pursue solutions that uphold justice without forsaking kindness—and show the love of Christ to all, even when the path forward feels uncertain.